Skip to content

Rework shark game on alcatraz

Suggestions
9 6 169
  • As it stands, shark game is just a favoritism game for whoever gets the shark. There's no element of luck, or skill, its simply whoever gets the shark decides who to kill. Of course sometimes CTs allow Ts to take a friend to LR with them, but this is only done late in the round. Allowing 10 Ts to die due to another Ts opinion is not a suitable game and doesn't belong in JB.

    CTs aren't allowed to participate in favoritism, and this is the only map game which uses this sort of mechanic with zero skill or luck.

    Rework suggestions:
    -Ts who control the shark are blind
    -Multiple sharks
    -Shark is not player controlled but instead random (like forklift game on seaside)

  • 🙂

  • To obtain the usage of the shark you have to be the first terrorist to reach of the top, I would argue this is a skill mechanic as it isn’t just random selection and requires terrorists to preform skilled manoeuvres to win. I do agree that the shark should be blinded to avoid favourtism in the game itself and I think having more than one shark would be a cool idea.

  • I understand the criticism and have felt like sharks are often favouring people they like to survive and I can agree, but it is indeed a skill based game in terms of reaching the shark first. This skill factor is extremely degraded by the use of jetpack, which I have attempted to prevent but could not reliably do so.

    I will NOT be having the shark CT controlled, I cannot (with map scripting) blind a singular T in a way in which they cannot read name plates, and multiple sharks just compounds the issue. As it stands, and has stood for years, (shark game was first on kibblet, I believe on CS:Source first before CSGO) the game is about murdering your fellow T's.

    Further suggestions are welcome from yourself or community, I am open to adjusting the game.

  • I understand the criticism and have felt like sharks are often favouring people they like to survive and I can agree, but it is indeed a skill based game in terms of reaching the shark first. This skill factor is extremely degraded by the use of jetpack, which I have attempted to prevent but could not reliably do so.

    I will NOT be having the shark CT controlled, I cannot (with map scripting) blind a singular T in a way in which they cannot read name plates, and multiple sharks just compounds the issue. As it stands, and has stood for years, (shark game was first on kibblet, I believe on CS:Source first before CSGO) the game is about murdering your fellow T's.

    Further suggestions are welcome from yourself or community, I am open to adjusting the game.

    @_rapids Could a rework be to randomise who gets the shark?
    Or make it so that the shark has to kill a certain number of players in a time limit, and they die if they don't - this will make the shark have stakes in the game
    Or make it a climb / kz to the shark instead of just a few jumps, this decreases the PTW aspect ie how useful / unnoticeable jetpack is in getting to the shark.

  • Favouritism is only a rule for CT's.
    T's being able to pick who they like is essentially an integral part of jailbreak - the most commonly played game at 3 T's left is literally just popularity.
    I see no issue as it is now.

  • Favouritism is only a rule for CT's.
    T's being able to pick who they like is essentially an integral part of jailbreak - the most commonly played game at 3 T's left is literally just popularity.
    I see no issue as it is now.

    @skink52 I think it's a bit different when shark game can be used to kill 10 Ts, and is usually played at the start of the round. I agree that Ts choosing who to live / die can be an integral part of the game, but this only really happens just for LR. The live / die game on wazza isn't really the same, as each T only gets to make the decision for one other T, and it typically spirals into the repetitive choosing of die if one chooses it.

    My point is that there is no other instance in which a T can, for the first map game of the round, unnoticeably jetpack in order to take 10 people out of the round for the remainder of the round, using their own opinion without any skill / luck basis.

  • Hey mate, jetpacks been nerfed a bit. if the cts notice someone jetpacking for it they can kill them or restart the game. It's the onus of the T who gets the shark to pick who they want to live or die. Maybe make some friends who will choose you to live. Else, get to the shark first.

  • Hey mate, jetpacks been nerfed a bit. if the cts notice someone jetpacking for it they can kill them or restart the game. It's the onus of the T who gets the shark to pick who they want to live or die. Maybe make some friends who will choose you to live. Else, get to the shark first.

    @uwunicorn Just my suggestion that it should be reworked to be different. As it stands shark game is the only map game that allows a singular T to basically order the death of 10 specific other Ts at the start of a round, every 3 rounds. If you don't see a problem with that then whatever